Category Archives: Musings

Liberty Hall

This is an update on one of my favorite weekly events – the Liberty Hall Flash challenge. Liberty Hall is a website hosted (kindly) by Mike Munsil, who has set up a long running system of challenges and motivational boards for speculative fiction writers(the sister site for literary writing is ShowMeYourLits).  The software is a bit glitchy at times, and sometimes the website is slow.  But I have been consistently entering challenges since August of 2010.  In fact, Liberty Hall is where I cut my teeth as a writer (hah, I’m still cutting my teeth).

Usually I stick with the flash challenges, although I’ve managed a few short story challenges and entered some work in the Polish challenge (where we enter something we think is ready to submit but want polishing help & opinions.  That one makes me nervous!

The flash challenges are fun and I have learned to pound out a story in far less than the 90 minutes allotted – which gives me time at the start to brainstorm, and time (sometimes) at the end to brush it up.  But I have relaxed about letting people see my rough drafts – and enjoyed finding out when I have the germ of something good.  The crits are brief, but usually everyone tries to find something of value in the draft stories, and often that can help trigger a new direction or new idea.

My “inventory” is bulging!  I’m leaning heavily on Write1Sub1 to get me to polish the flashes up and send them out.

Do you like external motivators or do you rely on yourself?

Reviewing Conundrums

One of my goals this year was to begin reviewing published books by the writers in my writing group, and writer friends, and writers I know.  I have reviewed books I own on LibraryThing, where I sometimes get free books and sometimes get ARCs.  The motivation to review (honestly) is to get more freebies!  And, it does help organize my books and my thoughts about them.

But reviewing on Amazon and Smashwords and commenting on Weightless books can pose a bit of a conundrum.

Sometimes it is obvious that a reviewer is just putting up a positive review to help their buddy – they don’t have any other reviews.  So if I’m going to review, I’d like to be a real reviewer, with helpful reviews of many books.  I began by putting some reviews up that I’d done on LibraryThing, classics and books by writers I don’t know.

But.

I came to a book I’d really not enjoyed and had put up a strong negative review on LibraryThing.  Many of the other readers had also disliked the book.  On Amazon, there are only positive reviews – 4 or 5 (perhaps friends?).  My ethical conundrum – do I put up the negative review and one star or do I just skip reviewing that book?  I feel uncomfortable because whoever this writer is, how helpful is the negative review?  Clearly with so few reviews, this book is unlikely to be a big seller, so it seems that low stars would only be personally hurtful to someone I’ve never met or interacted with.  Feels like anonymous aggression, I guess.

Currently my thoughts are that I would only post a review for books that I thought were 4 or 5 star, and simply not post for ones I thought were poorly written.  If I dislike the book for content, perhaps, where I can speak well of the writing or some aspect, so that other readers might truly enjoy the book (ie it is just a personal taste issue) then perhaps I would post a lower star review.

I guess my goal is to give reviews that other people would believe.  If all of one’s reviews are positive, do readers discount your opinion of  a particular book?  Would my reviews still be of value to my writer colleagues and friends?